Jerome Kern Tried to Keep His Songs Off the Radio. Jazz Musicians Adopted Them Anyway

In 1924 Jerome Kern banned every song from his new show, Sitting Pretty, from being broadcast or recorded. He wanted his music heard inside the show, the way he wrote it, and jazz versions are said to have been what bothered him most.

It didn’t work for long. Within a few years jazz musicians were recording Kern’s songs, and by the 1940s “All the Things You Are” was the tune every young bebop player in New York had to know.

These are 10 Jerome Kern songs that jazz made its own, counted down to the one musicians still call at jam sessions every night, with two or three recordings of each worth hearing. And at the end, the poker game that kept him off the Lusitania.

Jerome Kern songs: portrait of the young composer Jerome Kern around 1918
Jerome Kern – Musical Courier Company Inc., New York, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

10. “Long Ago (and Far Away)”

Kern wrote this with Ira Gershwin for the 1944 film Cover Girl, where Gene Kelly and Rita Hayworth sing it as a duet, with Hayworth’s voice dubbed by Martha Mears.

It sold more than 600,000 copies of sheet music in a year. It was nominated for the Academy Award for Best Original Song and lost to Bing Crosby’s “Swinging on a Star”.

Jazz players like it because it is simple and singable, which leaves plenty of room. Chet Baker recorded it in 1955 and did both jobs himself, singing the melody and then playing a trumpet solo in the same soft, close-up tone. More of that side of him is in our guide to Chet Baker Sings.

Start with: Chet Baker on Chet Baker Sings and Plays (1955). Listen for how little he changes the melody when he sings it, and how much he changes it when he picks up the trumpet.

Then try: Charlie Haden and Brad Mehldau on Long Ago and Far Away (recorded 2007, released 2018). A bass and piano duo, recorded live, that takes its time over every chord.

9. “Why Was I Born?”

Kern and Oscar Hammerstein II wrote this for Sweet Adeline, which opened in September 1929, a few weeks before the Wall Street crash. Helen Morgan sang it. She had already broken hearts as Julie in Show Boat, usually sitting on top of the piano.

The lyric is pure self-pity, which is why singers love it. Billie Holiday recorded it with Teddy Wilson and His Orchestra on 25 January 1937 and sang it lightly, almost shrugging, which makes the words hit harder.

The most unusual version came 64 years later. Sonny Rollins lived a few blocks from the World Trade Center and had been forced out of his apartment on 11 September, taking only his saxophone. Four days later he played a concert in Boston and stretched “Why Was I Born?” to around 16 minutes. That solo won him a Grammy.

Start with: Billie Holiday with Teddy Wilson and His Orchestra (Brunswick single, 1937). Under three minutes, and Lester Young-era small-band swing at its lightest.

Then try: Kenny Burrell and John Coltrane on Kenny Burrell & John Coltrane (recorded 1958, released 1963). Just guitar and tenor saxophone, with Coltrane playing the ballad straight and tender.

For something different: Sonny Rollins on Without a Song: The 9/11 Concert (recorded 2001, released 2005).

8. “I’m Old Fashioned”

In the 1942 film You Were Never Lovelier, Rita Hayworth sings this to Fred Astaire on a moonlit terrace and then they dance to it. Hayworth’s voice was dubbed again, this time by Nan Wynn. The words are by Johnny Mercer.

The melody moves in long, even notes, so it sounds plain on first hearing. Underneath, the chords keep slipping somewhere you don’t expect, and that is what jazz musicians hear in it.

John Coltrane picked it as the one ballad on Blue Train in 1957, his only album as a leader for Blue Note. Among five hard-driving tracks, it is the one where he slows right down.

Start with: John Coltrane on Blue Train (recorded 1957, released 1958). Lee Morgan’s trumpet solo, at 19, is worth the wait.

Then try: Chet Baker on It Could Happen to You (1958), sung rather than played.

For something different: Bill Charlap with Peter Bernstein and Peter Washington on I’m Old Fashioned (recorded 2009, released 2010). Piano, guitar and bass, no drums, and very quiet.

7. “The Song Is You”

Music in the Air opened at the Alvin Theatre in New York on 8 November 1932 and ran for 342 performances, a good run in the middle of the Depression. Tullio Carminati and Natalie Hall introduced “The Song Is You”.

Halfway through, the bridge jumps to a key a long way from home and then has to find its way back. For a singer it is a test of nerve. For an improviser it is a chance to show off, and that is why the beboppers liked it.

Charlie Parker recorded it with a quartet in December 1952, taking it fast and making the key change sound easy.

Start with: Charlie Parker on Now’s the Time (recorded 1952, released 1956).

Then try: Lee Konitz, Brad Mehldau and Charlie Haden on Alone Together (1997). A saxophone, piano and bass trio with no drums, recorded live, that turns the tune into a long, slow conversation.

6. “Yesterdays”

“Yesterdays” came from Roberta in 1933, the same score as “Smoke Gets in Your Eyes”. It was sung by Fay Templeton, who had been a star of the 1890s stage, so a song about lost days had real weight coming from her.

It is in a minor key and moves down step by step, which gives it a dark, heavy mood that pianists and saxophonists love to lean into.

Billie Holiday recorded it for Commodore on 20 April 1939, at the same session that produced “Strange Fruit”.

Start with: Billie Holiday (Commodore single, 1939).

Then try: Clifford Brown on Clifford Brown with Strings (1955). Brown plays the melody almost unchanged over a string section, and his tone does all the work.

For something different: Fred Hersch and Bill Frisell on Songs We Know (1998), a piano and guitar duo.

5. “A Fine Romance”

On the original sheet music, Kern and Dorothy Fields called this “a sarcastic love song”. In the 1936 film Swing Time, Ginger Rogers sings it to Fred Astaire on a snowy drive, complaining that he is about as warm as yesterday’s mashed potatoes, before she slams the car door and drives off.

Kern didn’t find upbeat dance numbers easy. As Mark Steyn tells it, Astaire wanted to know whether Kern could write anything hot, and while they worked on Swing Time he tapped up and down Fields’ living room and stairs until Kern caught the beat.

Ella Fitzgerald and Louis Armstrong recorded it on their second album together and turned the argument into a comedy act. More of Ella’s best work is in our guide to the best Ella Fitzgerald albums.

Start with: Ella Fitzgerald and Louis Armstrong on Ella and Louis Again (1957). Listen to Armstrong’s growl answering Ella’s lines.

Then try: Stacey Kent on Let Yourself Go (2000), from an album of songs from the Astaire films.

4. “Ol’ Man River”

Show Boat opened on Broadway on 27 December 1927, written by Kern and Hammerstein. A musical about racism, with a racially mixed cast, was something new on Broadway, and “Ol’ Man River” was at its centre.

Paul Robeson turned down the part of Joe in New York, so Jules Bledsoe sang it on opening night. Robeson played Joe in London the next year, and the song stayed with him for life. From around 1938 he changed several lines in concert, turning a song about weary endurance into one of defiance.

Jazz got there almost at once. Paul Whiteman’s orchestra had a hit with it in early 1928, with Bing Crosby singing and Bix Beiderbecke on cornet, at a far faster tempo than Kern and Hammerstein had in mind.

Start with: Paul Whiteman and His Orchestra with Bing Crosby and Bix Beiderbecke (78 rpm single, 1928). It sounds nothing like the show, which is the point.

Then try: Keith Jarrett, solo piano, on Tokyo Solo (DVD, recorded 2002, released 2006).

3. “Smoke Gets in Your Eyes”

The melody took six years to find its song. Kern first wrote it as a quick tap number for Show Boat in 1927, where it was dropped, and in 1932 he tried it as a march for a radio theme. For Roberta in 1933, Kern slowed it right down into a ballad, with words by Otto Harbach. Harbach later claimed the slower tempo was his idea, which reportedly irritated Kern.

Tamara Drasin introduced it on Broadway in November 1933, and Paul Whiteman’s 1934 recording, sung by Bob Lawrence, went to number one.

The best-known fight over a Kern song came after he died. When the Platters’ doo-wop version reached number one in 1958–59, his widow, Eva, disliked it so much that she started legal action to stop it. She dropped the case when she saw how much it was selling and how big her royalties would be. Harbach, according to the Platters’ producer Buck Ram, praised the group for reviving his song “with taste”.

The bridge, like the one in “The Song Is You”, leaps to a distant key. Thelonious Monk recorded it in 1954 and pulled the melody apart, with odd pauses and crunching chords, while never losing the tune.

Start with: Thelonious Monk on Monk (recorded May 1954), with Frank Foster on tenor saxophone and Art Blakey on drums.

Then try: Keith Jarrett Trio on Tribute (recorded live in Cologne in 1989, released 1990), with Gary Peacock and Jack DeJohnette.

For the story: The Platters’ 1958 single, the version Kern’s widow tried to stop.

2. “The Way You Look Tonight”

In Swing Time (1936), Fred Astaire sits at the piano and sings this to Ginger Rogers, who is in the next room washing her hair. She walks in to listen with her head covered in shampoo.

Dorothy Fields wrote the words. She described the first time she heard Kern play the melody in Max Wilk’s book They’re Playing Our Song: “I went out and started to cry. The release absolutely killed me.” The release is the middle section, and it is the part every arranger since has made a fuss of. The song won the Academy Award for Best Original Song.

Teddy Wilson recorded it with a 21-year-old Billie Holiday in October 1936. Benny Goodman’s 1942 version, with Peggy Lee, put it back in the charts.

Start with: Teddy Wilson and His Orchestra with Billie Holiday (single, 1936).

Then try: Thelonious Monk and Sonny Rollins on Thelonious Monk and Sonny Rollins (recorded 1954). Taken at a gallop, with Rollins at 24 already sounding like himself.

For something different: Tony Bennett and Bill Charlap on The Silver Lining: The Songs of Jerome Kern (2015), recorded when Bennett was in his late 80s.

1. “All the Things You Are”

Very Warm for May opened on 17 November 1939 and closed after 59 performances. It was Kern’s last Broadway show, and it would be forgotten if not for one song, with words by Hammerstein.

The melody keeps changing key, travelling through several before the bridge moves to G and then E major and the tune finally comes home to A-flat. Tommy Dorsey’s recording, sung by Jack Leonard, was a hit in early 1940.

For jazz musicians, all those key changes made it a workout, and learning it became a rite of passage. Charlie Parker wrote “Bird of Paradise” on its chords in 1947. In May 1953, Parker, Dizzy Gillespie, Bud Powell, Charles Mingus and Max Roach played it at Massey Hall in Toronto, at the concert later released as Jazz at Massey Hall.

Start with: The Quintet on Jazz at Massey Hall (1953). Five of the key figures of bebop on one stage, for one night.

Then try: Keith Jarrett Trio on Tribute (recorded 1989, released 1990), the same album as their “Smoke Gets in Your Eyes”.

For something different: Gonzalo Rubalcaba with Charlie Haden and Paul Motian on Discovery: Live at Montreux (recorded 1990), the set that introduced the Cuban pianist to many listeners outside Cuba.

The boat he missed, and his last week in New York

In May 1915 Kern was booked to sail to London on the Lusitania with the producer Charles Frohman. By the usual account, he played poker late the night before, overslept and missed the boat. Frohman died when the ship was torpedoed. Every song on this list came after that morning.

Thirty years later, in November 1945, Kern came back to New York to work on a revival of Show Boat and a new musical about Annie Oakley. On 5 November he collapsed with a cerebral haemorrhage at the corner of Park Avenue and 57th Street. He was carrying only his ASCAP membership card, and was at first taken to the ward for the destitute at City Hospital.

He died on 11 November, aged 60, with Hammerstein beside him. Hammerstein sang or hummed “I’ve Told Ev’ry Little Star” to him, and realised he had gone when there was no response.

The Annie Oakley show went to Irving Berlin and became Annie Get Your Gun. Berlin couldn’t read music and played the piano almost entirely in F-sharp, and how he wrote that score is in our Irving Berlin songs article.

Note: As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Which version of “All the Things You Are” would you put first? Tell us in the comments.

Meet Your Guide

Matt Fripp (about)

Matt Fripp

Founder & host of Jazzfuel

Matt Fripp studied jazz saxophone at London's Guildhall School of Music, then spent a decade behind the scenes as a booking agent and manager for a roster of international jazz artists worldwide. Since 2016 he's run Jazzfuel, helping close to a million readers a year dig deeper into the albums, musicians and stories that shaped jazz.
More about Jazzfuel →

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.