Irving Berlin couldn’t read music. He played the piano almost entirely in F-sharp, mostly on the black keys, using a special piano with a lever that shifted the keyboard into other keys, and he sang or played his tunes to a “musical secretary” who wrote them down.
He still wrote around 1,500 songs. In 1924 Jerome Kern summed him up in a letter to Berlin’s first biographer, Alexander Woollcott: “Irving Berlin has no place in American music — he is American music.”
These are 10 Irving Berlin songs jazz musicians still play, counted down to the one that stole another songwriting team’s opening night, with two or three recordings of each worth hearing.
10. “Change Partners”
Berlin wrote “Change Partners” for Carefree (1938), the last of his three films for Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers. Astaire sings it to a woman who is dancing every dance with the same man, asking her to swap him for the singer.
It was nominated for the Academy Award and lost to “Thanks for the Memory”. The melody is one long, smooth line, which suits a saxophone as well as a voice.
Start with: Frank Sinatra and Antônio Carlos Jobim on Francis Albert Sinatra & Antônio Carlos Jobim (1967), which turns it into a quiet bossa nova.
Then try: Fred Hersch Trio on Night & the Music (2007).
9. “Isn’t This a Lovely Day (to Be Caught in the Rain?)”
In Top Hat (1935), Ginger Rogers shelters from a thunderstorm in a bandstand, and Fred Astaire turns up and sings her this. The dance that follows starts with the two of them mocking each other’s steps and ends with a handshake.
The lyric turns bad weather into an excuse to stay put, and the melody is gentle enough to take at a slow, chatty pace. That made it a natural duet for jazz singers.
Start with: Ella Fitzgerald and Louis Armstrong on Ella and Louis (1956), with Oscar Peterson’s rhythm section. Listen for Armstrong’s gravel answering Ella’s lines. More on that pairing in our guides to Louis Armstrong and the best Ella Fitzgerald albums.
For the story: Fred Astaire’s own 1935 recording from the film.
8. “Remember”
In 1925 Berlin was courting Ellin Mackay, a young heiress whose father, the head of the Postal Telegraph company, wanted nothing to do with a songwriter from the Lower East Side. Berlin wrote “Remember” that year, and he is said to have used it and “All Alone” to woo her over the radio. The couple eloped the following January.
It is a waltz, and jazz players usually straighten it out into four.
Start with: Hank Mobley on Soul Station (1960), the opening track, with Wynton Kelly, Paul Chambers and Art Blakey. Mobley’s tenor saxophone sounds relaxed and warm all the way through.
Then try: Thelonious Monk on Thelonious Alone in San Francisco (1959), solo piano.
For something different: Jim Rotondi on Destination Up! (2001), with trumpet, trombone and vibraphone up front.
7. “What’ll I Do?”
Berlin wrote this waltz in 1923 for his Music Box Revue, staged at a theatre he had built himself with the producer Sam Harris. Grace Moore and John Steel introduced it.
Twelve years earlier, his first wife, Dorothy Goetz, had caught typhoid on their honeymoon in Havana and died within months. That grief had produced “When I Lost You”, his first ballad, and “What’ll I Do?” carries the same ache.
Start with: Chet Baker on She Was Too Good to Me (1974), sung softly over a CTI string section.
Then try: Charlie Haden and Brad Mehldau on Long Ago and Far Away (recorded 2007, released 2018).
6. “I’ve Got My Love to Keep Me Warm”
Berlin wrote this for the 1937 film On the Avenue, where Dick Powell and Alice Faye introduced it. The lyric is about a snowstorm and never mentions Christmas, but it ended up on Christmas albums by Rosemary Clooney, Dean Martin, Frank Sinatra and Dinah Washington.
Billie Holiday recorded it weeks before the film came out. The bandleader Les Brown recorded an instrumental version in 1946, and when it was released in 1949 it sold a million copies.
Start with: Billie Holiday and Her Orchestra (single, 1937).
Then try: Les Brown and His Band of Renown (Columbia single, released 1949), the swing-band hit, with no singer at all.
5. “Let’s Face the Music and Dance”
For Follow the Fleet (1936), Astaire and Rogers danced to this in one continuous shot of almost three minutes. On the first take, the heavy sleeve of Rogers’ dress swung round and hit Astaire in the face. They did about twenty more takes, and he still chose the first.
The song starts in a minor key and breaks into a bolder major section, and the lyric’s mix of trouble ahead and defiance keeps singers coming back to it.
Start with: Fred Astaire with Johnny Green and His Orchestra (Brunswick single, 1936).
Then try: Diana Krall on When I Look in Your Eyes (1999), the opening track, with an orchestral arrangement by Johnny Mandel.
4. “They Say It’s Wonderful”
Annie Get Your Gun was meant to be a Jerome Kern score. When Kern died in November 1945, the producers, Richard Rodgers and Oscar Hammerstein II, gave the job to Berlin. The show opened in 1946 with Ethel Merman as Annie Oakley.
“They Say It’s Wonderful” has Annie wondering whether falling in love is as good as people say. In 1963 John Coltrane and the singer Johnny Hartman made it the opening track of their only album together, and Hartman’s deep, unhurried baritone made it a jazz ballad for good.
Start with: John Coltrane and Johnny Hartman on John Coltrane and Johnny Hartman (1963).
Then try: Kurt Elling on Dedicated to You (2009), recorded live at Jazz at Lincoln Center as a tribute to that album.
3. “How Deep Is the Ocean?”
By 1932 Berlin was in a slump. His infant son had died in 1928, and after the Wall Street crash he started to doubt he could still write. Then a friend gave one of his filed-away songs, “Say It Isn’t So”, to Rudy Vallée, and it was a hit.
Encouraged, Berlin wrote “How Deep Is the Ocean?”. Almost every line of the lyric is a question. It starts in a minor key, ends in the major and has no real bridge, which leaves a soloist plenty of room.
Start with: Charlie Parker (Dial, 1947), a slow ballad from the bebop years.
Then try: Joshua Redman on Timeless Tales (For Changing Times) (1998).
2. “Cheek to Cheek”
Top Hat (1935) was Berlin’s first film with Astaire and Rogers, and “Cheek to Cheek” became its big number. Part of it began as “Moon Over Napoli”, written for a Broadway show that never happened.
At 72 bars, it is the longest song Berlin wrote, more than twice the length of a standard 32-bar tune, with a section that drops into a minor key before coming home. Astaire’s recording went to number one, and Berlin gave him the credit.
Start with: Billie Holiday on All or Nothing at All (recorded 1956), with Ben Webster on tenor saxophone.
Then try: Tony Bennett and Lady Gaga on Cheek to Cheek (2014), the album that took Berlin’s song back into the charts.
1. “Blue Skies”
In December 1926 the singer Belle Baker was starring in Betsy, a Ziegfeld show with a score by Richard Rodgers and Lorenz Hart. She didn’t like her big number, so she asked her old friend Berlin for a song. He gave her one he had just finished, reportedly written for the birth of his first daughter.
It went into the show without Rodgers and Hart being asked. On opening night, 28 December 1926, Baker reportedly took 24 encores. Betsy closed within about a month.
The next year Al Jolson sang “Blue Skies” in The Jazz Singer, the first feature film with synchronised singing. For jazz musicians the hook is the way it starts in a minor key and breaks into the major, over a bass line that walks downwards. Thelonious Monk liked the chords enough to build his own tune, “In Walked Bud”, on them.
Start with: Benny Goodman and His Orchestra on The Famous 1938 Carnegie Hall Jazz Concert (recorded 1938), in Fletcher Henderson’s arrangement.
Then try: Ella Fitzgerald on Ella Fitzgerald Sings the Irving Berlin Song Book (1958), where she takes off into a long scat chorus.
A wedding present and 101 years
Berlin married Ellin Mackay in January 1926, against her father’s wishes, and gave her the rights to “Always”, one of the songs he wrote while falling in love with her, as a wedding present. They were married until her death in July 1988.
He officially retired after Mr. President in 1962, came back once to write a new song for a 1966 revival of Annie Get Your Gun, and then almost vanished from public life. He died in New York on 22 September 1989, aged 101.
Berlin wrote his own words and music, and so did Cole Porter, who had written around 300 songs before he left Yale. His story is in our Cole Porter songs article.
Note: As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Which Irving Berlin song has the best jazz version? Tell us in the comments.