Cole Porter had written around 300 songs before he left Yale. He grew up rich, wrote both the words and the music, and filled his lyrics with jokes, lists and double meanings that radio censors kept trying to cut.
Under the jokes, his melodies often sit in minor keys, run longer than usual and slip between major and minor. That’s the side of Porter jazz musicians fell for.
These are 10 Cole Porter songs, counted down to his most famous, with two or three recordings of each worth hearing. And at the end, the riding accident that should have stopped him writing.
10. “It’s All Right with Me”
Peter Cookson introduced this in Can-Can (1953), playing a judge who has fallen for a woman he knows is wrong for him. The lyric shrugs: it’s the wrong time and the wrong place, but it’s all right with him.
Pianists in particular love it, because it works at almost any speed.
Start with: Erroll Garner on Concert by the Sea (recorded 1955), recorded live at Carmel-by-the-Sea. Listen to his left hand strumming the beat like a rhythm guitar.
Then try: Harry Connick Jr. on We Are in Love (1990).
9. “From This Moment On”
Porter wrote this in 1950 for Out of This World, and the director George Abbott cut it before the show reached Broadway. Three years later MGM put it into the film of Kiss Me Kate, where Ann Miller, Tommy Rall, Bob Fosse and Bobby Van danced to it.
Start with: Ella Fitzgerald on Ella Fitzgerald Sings the Cole Porter Song Book (1956), with Buddy Bregman’s orchestra. It’s one of the best Ella Fitzgerald albums.
Then try: Frank Sinatra on A Swingin’ Affair! (1957), with Nelson Riddle’s brass driving it along.
8. “Begin the Beguine”
Porter wrote “Begin the Beguine” on a world cruise in 1935, and it went into the show Jubilee that autumn, where almost nobody noticed it.
At 108 bars, it is more than three times the length of a typical popular song. When Artie Shaw recorded it in 1938, RCA Victor doubted anyone could remember a tune that long and put it on the B-side. It became one of the best-selling records of the swing era.
Start with: Artie Shaw and His Orchestra (Bluebird single, 1938), in Jerry Gray’s arrangement, with Shaw’s clarinet floating over the top.
Then try: Tuck Andress on Reckless Precision (1990), all 108 bars on one solo guitar.
7. “Let’s Do It, Let’s Fall in Love”
Porter spent most of the 1920s in Paris with little success on Broadway. That changed with Paris (1928), where the French singer Irène Bordoni introduced “Let’s Do It”, and his American career finally took off.
It’s a list song, with birds, bees, fish and assorted animals all doing “it”. Singers have been writing their own verses ever since, and Noël Coward wrote a whole new set for his Las Vegas act in 1955.
Start with: Billie Holiday (single, 1941).
Then try: Dee Dee Bridgewater on Dear Ella (1997), her big-band tribute to Ella Fitzgerald.
6. “I Love You”
According to his biographer Charles Schwartz, Porter wrote “I Love You” on a bet. The actor Monty Woolley bet him he couldn’t write a hit with a title that worn out. Bing Crosby’s recording of it spent five weeks at number one in 1944.
The melody opens with a big drop and then a leap back up, and a few bars later it lurches into a new key, which is what caught jazz players’ ears.
Start with: Bill Evans on New Jazz Conceptions (1956), his first album as a leader.
Then try: John Coltrane on Lush Life (recorded 1957), a trio track with no piano, just bass and drums behind his tenor saxophone.
5. “I Get a Kick Out of You”
Porter wrote this for a show that never happened, then put it into Anything Goes in 1934, where Ethel Merman sang it.
The original lyric has the singer getting no kick from cocaine. Hollywood’s censors wouldn’t allow that in the 1936 film, and later singers, Frank Sinatra among them, swapped in “perfume from Spain”.
Start with: Charlie Parker (Verve, 1954), collected on The Cole Porter Songbook.
Then try: Tony Bennett and Lady Gaga on Love for Sale (2021), a whole album of Porter songs and Bennett’s last studio record.
4. “What Is This Thing Called Love?”
Elsie Carlisle introduced this in London in March 1929, in the revue Wake Up and Dream. Porter claimed the switches between major and minor came from a dance he had heard in Morocco, though nothing in the song mentions Morocco.
The beboppers loved those chords. Tadd Dameron wrote “Hot House” on them, and Lee Konitz wrote “Subconscious-Lee”. More on that generation is in our guide to the best bebop musicians and albums.
Start with: Clifford Brown and Max Roach on At Basin Street (1956), at full tilt, with Sonny Rollins on tenor saxophone.
Then try: Jacky Terrasson and Stefon Harris on Kindred (2001), piano and vibraphone.
3. “I’ve Got You Under My Skin”
Virginia Bruce introduced this in the 1936 film Born to Dance. It was nominated for the Academy Award and lost to Jerome Kern’s “The Way You Look Tonight”.
Twenty years later Frank Sinatra recorded it with a Nelson Riddle arrangement that keeps building, bar after bar, until a trombone solo by Milt Bernhart blows the roof off. Riddle said the idea came from Ravel’s Boléro.
Start with: Frank Sinatra on Songs for Swingin’ Lovers! (1956).
Then try: Bill Evans and Jim Hall on Intermodulation (1966), just piano and guitar.
2. “Love for Sale”
The New Yorkers opened in December 1930, and in it Kathryn Crawford sang “Love for Sale” as a streetwalker outside a New York restaurant. Critics were shocked, radio stations refused to play it, and the ban only helped. Libby Holman’s recording reached number five in 1931.
A month into the run, the Black singer Elizabeth Welch took over the number and the scene was moved to Harlem, outside the Cotton Club. Like “Begin the Beguine”, it runs far longer than a normal song and moves between minor and major.
Start with: Cannonball Adderley with Miles Davis on Somethin’ Else (1958), at a cool, relaxed tempo, with Davis on muted trumpet.
Then try: Dexter Gordon on Go! (1962), taken much faster.
1. “Night and Day”
Fred Astaire introduced “Night and Day” in Gay Divorce in November 1932, his last Broadway show before Hollywood. His recording was one of the biggest hits of 1933.
Porter gave several accounts of where it came from, including an Islamic call to prayer he had heard in Morocco. The verse keeps hammering one repeated note, like a clock ticking, over chords that shift underneath it, and the chorus runs to 48 bars instead of the usual 32.
Billie Holiday recorded it in December 1939, with Lester Young and Buck Clayton in the band.
Start with: Billie Holiday (Vocalion single, 1939).
Then try: Kenny Garrett on Triology (1995), alto saxophone, bass and drums with no piano, which leaves the chords wide open.
The fall at Piping Rock
On 24 October 1937, at the Piping Rock Club on Long Island, Porter’s horse fell and rolled on him, crushing both legs. He was in pain for the rest of his life and went through more than 30 operations.
He kept writing anyway. Kiss Me Kate, which won the first Tony Award for best musical, Can-Can and Silk Stockings all came after the accident. In 1958 his right leg was amputated, and he wrote very little after that. He died in Santa Monica in October 1964, aged 73.
George Gershwin’s start was very different: he left school at 15 to plug songs on Tin Pan Alley for $15 a week. That story is in our George Gershwin songs article.
Note: As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Which Cole Porter song has the best jazz version? Tell us in the comments.