At 15, George Gershwin left school to plug other people’s songs on Tin Pan Alley for $15 a week. His own first published song, in 1916, earned him 50 cents.
Twenty years later he was dead, at 38. In between he wrote Rhapsody in Blue, an opera and, with his brother Ira on lyrics, a pile of songs that jazz musicians have never stopped playing. One of them supplied the chords for half of bebop.
These are 10 George Gershwin songs, counted down to the most recorded of them all, with two or three recordings of each worth hearing. And at the end, the warning signs his doctors missed.
10. “They Can’t Take That Away from Me”
Fred Astaire sang this to Ginger Rogers in Shall We Dance, which opened in May 1937. Two months later Gershwin was dead, so its Oscar nomination came after he had gone. It lost to “Sweet Leilani”.
Ira’s lyric is a list of small, specific memories, like the way she wears her hat and the way she sips her tea, which gives singers something real to hold on to.
Start with: Diana Krall on Love Scenes (1997), a drummer-less trio with Russell Malone on guitar and Christian McBride on bass.
For the story: Fred Astaire’s 1937 recording from the film.
9. “A Foggy Day”
By 1937 the Gershwins were in Hollywood, and “A Foggy Day (In London Town)” was written for Astaire in A Damsel in Distress. The fog was London’s famous “pea souper”, the thick, yellow, polluted kind.
Charles Mingus moved it across the Atlantic. On Pithecanthropus Erectus in 1956 he recorded it as “A Foggy Day (In San Francisco)”, complete with car horns, sirens and street noise played by the band.
Start with: Frank Sinatra on Songs for Young Lovers (1954).
Then try: Charles Mingus on Pithecanthropus Erectus (1956), for the traffic jam.
8. “Love Is Here to Stay”
This was the last song George Gershwin completed, for The Goldwyn Follies in 1937. Ira finished the lyric after his brother died. George hadn’t written a verse, so the composer Vernon Duke pieced one together from bits Ira and the pianist Oscar Levant remembered him playing.
It barely registered in the 1938 film. It took off in 1951, when Gene Kelly sang it to Leslie Caron by the Seine in An American in Paris.
Start with: Frank Sinatra on Songs for Swingin’ Lovers! (1956), with Nelson Riddle.
Then try: Marcus Roberts on Gershwin for Lovers (1994), a piano trio taking its time.
7. “Oh, Lady Be Good!”
Lady, Be Good! opened on Broadway in December 1924, starring Fred and Adele Astaire, the first show George and Ira wrote together. Gershwin marked the title song “slow and gracefully”. Jazz players ignored him.
In 1936 the producer John Hammond recorded a small group from Count Basie’s band in Chicago, under the name Jones-Smith Incorporated. Basie took the first chorus and a young Lester Young took the second, and that solo became one that saxophonists learned note for note.
Start with: Jones-Smith Incorporated with Lester Young and Count Basie (single, 1936).
Then try: Ella Fitzgerald (Decca single, 1947), a hit built around a long scat solo.
6. “But Not for Me”
A 19-year-old Ginger Rogers introduced this in Girl Crazy in 1930. Ira’s lyric is self-pitying and funny at once: everyone else is writing love songs, but not for her.
Jazz instrumentalists picked it up in the 1950s, and Ahmad Jamal made it the opening track of his live album At the Pershing, a record full of space and silence that Miles Davis admired.
Start with: Chet Baker on Chet Baker Sings (1954), the vocal version most people know. More in our piece on Chet Baker Sings.
Then try: Ahmad Jamal on At the Pershing: But Not for Me (1958).
5. “Embraceable You”
George and Ira wrote this in 1928 for an operetta that was never produced, then put it into Girl Crazy two years later.
For many jazz fans, the version that matters is Charlie Parker’s, recorded for Dial in October 1947 with Miles Davis and Max Roach in the band. Parker barely plays the written melody at all. He starts improvising almost straight away, turning a love song into something new, and a few weeks later he wrote his own tune, “Quasimodo”, on its chords.
Start with: Charlie Parker Quintet (Dial, 1947).
Then try: Joe Lovano on 52nd Street Themes (2000), which closes with it.
4. “The Man I Love”
Few standards had a worse start. It was cut from Lady, Be Good! in 1924, went into Strike Up the Band in 1927, which closed before reaching Broadway, and was dropped from Rosalie in 1928. Lady Mountbatten, a friend of Gershwin’s, had dance bands play it in England, and it caught on there first.
Musicians like the bass line, which keeps creeping downwards under the melody.
Start with: Coleman Hawkins Swing Four (Signature single, 1943), at double the usual tempo, with Oscar Pettiford’s bass pushing it along.
Then try: Billie Holiday with Lester Young (single, 1939), slow and close.
For something different: Herbie Hancock with Joni Mitchell on Gershwin’s World (1998).
3. “Someone to Watch Over Me”
The Gershwins first wrote this as a fast number. George tried it slowly, and they never went back. Gertrude Lawrence introduced it in Oh, Kay! in November 1926, singing it alone on stage to a rag doll.
Some of its phrases run to nine bars instead of eight, which can catch out a band that’s counting. It’s one of the best jazz ballads.
Start with: Ella Fitzgerald with Ellis Larkins on Ella Sings Gershwin (1950). Just voice and piano, and quieter than her later songbooks.
Then try: Samara Joy with Pasquale Grasso on Linger Awhile (2022), from the album that won her a Grammy.
2. “I Got Rhythm”
Girl Crazy opened in October 1930 with a remarkable pit band: Benny Goodman, Glenn Miller, Jack Teagarden, Jimmy Dorsey and Gene Krupa. Ethel Merman, in her Broadway debut, sang “I Got Rhythm” and held one note for sixteen bars while the orchestra played the tune around her.
For jazz musicians the chords matter more than the melody. Known as “rhythm changes”, they sit under dozens of later tunes, including “Lester Leaps In”, “Salt Peanuts”, “Anthropology” and Monk’s “Rhythm-a-ning”. Learning them is still one of the first jobs for any young jazz player.
Start with: Don Byas and Slam Stewart (live at Town Hall, 1945). Just tenor saxophone and bass, no drums and no piano, racing through the changes.
Then try: Tony Bennett and Diana Krall on Love Is Here to Stay (2018), a whole album of Gershwin.
1. “Summertime”
“Summertime” opens Porgy and Bess, the opera Gershwin wrote with DuBose Heyward, the author of the novel it’s based on. Heyward wrote these words, not Ira. In the first scene a young mother, Clara, sings it to her baby.
Abbie Mitchell made the first recording in July 1935, with Gershwin at the piano. The show opened on Broadway that October and lost money, but the lullaby escaped. Its melody sits close to a five-note folk scale, which makes it feel older than it is, and it has been recorded well over a thousand times, more than almost any other jazz standard.
Start with: Sidney Bechet (Blue Note single, 1939), one of the first records on the new Blue Note label, with Bechet’s soprano saxophone soaring over it.
Then try: Miles Davis and Gil Evans on Porgy and Bess (1958), Davis’s trumpet floating over Evans’s orchestra.
For the story: Billie Holiday’s 1936 recording, the first version to reach the pop charts.
The smell of burning rubber
In February 1937, playing his own Concerto in F at a concert in Los Angeles, Gershwin lost control of his hands for a few moments. Over the next months he had blackouts, severe headaches and kept noticing a smell of burning rubber. Doctors found nothing and put it down to stress.
On 9 July he collapsed at the lyricist Yip Harburg’s house. Surgeons found a brain tumour and operated, and he died on the morning of 11 July, aged 38.
Ira lived until 1983 and kept writing. With Harold Arlen he wrote “The Man That Got Away” for Judy Garland, and how Arlen’s “Over the Rainbow” nearly got cut from The Wizard of Oz is in our Harold Arlen songs article.
Note: As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Which George Gershwin song has the best jazz version? Tell us in the comments.