“The Worst Thing I Ever Heard”: How Marvin Gaye Got What’s Going On Past Berry Gordy

Berry Gordy did not want Marvin Gaye to make “What’s Going On”. By the most widely repeated account, the head of Motown called the finished single the worst thing he had ever heard. Gordy has since denied saying it, and disputes parts of the story that follows, but he has never hidden that he didn’t want Motown putting out a protest record.

When his head of A&R, Harry Balk, kept pushing for it, Gordy told him it sounded dated. Balk remembered the objection precisely: “that Dizzy Gillespie stuff in the middle, that scatting, it’s old.”

The single came out in January 1971, without Gordy’s approval according to the executives who released it. It became the fastest-selling record Motown had released up to that point.

From People’s Park to Hitsville

The song didn’t start with Marvin Gaye. In May 1969, Renaldo “Obie” Benson of the Four Tops was on tour in California when he saw police attacking protesters at People’s Park in Berkeley. He started writing about it with the Motown lyricist Al Cleveland.

The rest of the Four Tops wouldn’t touch it. “My partners told me it was a protest song,” Benson later said. He also played it to Joan Baez, but nothing came of it.

Gaye first wanted it for The Originals, a group he was producing. Benson persuaded him to sing it himself by offering him a share of the songwriting. Gaye reworked the melody and lyrics, and the finished song is credited to all three men.

A singer who had stopped singing

By 1970 Gaye was in no state to record hits. In October 1967 his duet partner Tammi Terrell had collapsed in his arms on stage at Hampden–Sydney College in Virginia. A brain tumour was diagnosed, and after eight operations she died on 16 March 1970, aged 24.

Gaye stopped performing live, grew a beard and refused to promote his latest album. He even sought a trial with the Detroit Lions as a professional footballer.

His younger brother Frankie had served in Vietnam as an army radio operator. Gaye drew on what Frankie told him about the war for the songs he was now writing. One of them, “What’s Happening Brother”, was written about Frankie’s return.

Marvin Gaye in a 1973 Tamla publicity photo, two years after What's Going On
Marvin Gaye – Tamla, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

A party in Studio A

The rhythm track for “What’s Going On” was cut in early June 1970 in Studio A at Hitsville U.S.A., Motown’s house-turned-studio in Detroit, with the Funk Brothers, the label’s house band. Gaye added his vocals in July, and David Van DePitte’s string arrangement went on in September.

Gaye wanted it to sound like a gathering of friends. The voices chatting at the start belong partly to two Detroit Lions players, Mel Farr and Lem Barney, along with The Miracles’ Bobby Rogers.

The saxophone line that opens the record wasn’t planned. Eli Fontaine said he was just fooling around on his alto; Gaye told him he had goofed off exquisitely, and kept it. One Funk Brothers story, retold by Sound On Sound, says bassist James Jamerson played his part lying on the studio floor because he was too drunk to sit up. Van DePitte, who wrote the bass part, only ever said that Jamerson read it exactly as written.

That Dizzy Gillespie stuff

What Gordy heard was a record that broke most of Motown’s rules. It didn’t build to a big chorus, and the groove floated rather than stomped. Over it, Gaye stacked his own voice in layers, sliding into wordless, scat-like phrases in the breaks midway through.

To Gordy’s ear that was the sound of a past era, the bebop vocal style associated with Dizzy Gillespie. The objection wasn’t ignorance of jazz. Motown engineer Bob Olhsson later said Gordy was a jazz lover who simply couldn’t see the record restarting Gaye’s career.

Gordy’s bigger worry was the subject. Speaking to Marc Myers in 2011, he said he liked the song but not the idea of Motown “coming out with a protest album”. Earlier, when Gaye phoned to tell him what he planned, Gordy, away on holiday, asked why he wanted to ruin his career.

Released behind his back

With the single stalled, Gaye reportedly went on strike, refusing to record anything else until it came out. Gordy says that never happened.

Balk, meanwhile, had been given an acetate of the song by mistake and kept playing it to visitors. While Gordy was away, Balk persuaded Barney Ales, Motown’s vice president of sales, that the label would get nothing more from its biggest male star unless it gave way. Ales ordered a pressing of 100,000 copies without telling Gordy.

The single was released on 20 January 1971. The first 100,000 sold out almost at once, and Motown pressed another 100,000.

“What’s Going On” reached No. 1 on Billboard’s soul singles chart, staying there for five weeks, and spent three weeks at No. 2 on the Hot 100 in April 1971. It was kept off the top first by the Temptations’ “Just My Imagination (Running Away with Me)”, another Motown single, and then by Three Dog Night’s “Joy to the World”.

Ten days in March

Once the single was a hit, Gordy wanted an album, quickly. Gaye recorded it in Detroit between 17 and 30 March 1971, around ten working days. He then flew to Los Angeles and remixed much of it in May, bringing the orchestra forward. Gordy approved the new mix over the objections of his own quality control team.

What’s Going On came out on Tamla on 21 May 1971 as a continuous suite, the songs running into each other without breaks. It was the first of his own albums Gaye produced himself, and it reached No. 6 on the Billboard album chart, his first top-ten LP.

The original Detroit mix was eventually issued on CD in 2001, and the 2011 40th-anniversary set includes it on vinyl, so you can hear how different the record nearly sounded.

In 2020, Rolling Stone named What’s Going On the greatest album of all time. Gordy had already given his own verdict on the whole episode: he said he was thrilled to have been proved wrong.

Featured image: Marvin Gaye – Tamla, Public domain, adapted, via Wikimedia Commons

Meet Your Guide

Matt Fripp (about)

Matt Fripp

Founder & host of Jazzfuel

Matt Fripp studied jazz saxophone at London's Guildhall School of Music, then spent a decade behind the scenes as a booking agent and manager for a roster of international jazz artists worldwide. Since 2016 he's run Jazzfuel, helping close to a million readers a year dig deeper into the albums, musicians and stories that shaped jazz.
More about Jazzfuel →

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.