On the morning of Sunday 15 September 1963, a bomb went off at the 16th Street Baptist Church in Birmingham, Alabama, at about 10:22. Four girls were killed: Addie Mae Collins, Cynthia Wesley and Carole Robertson, all 14, and Carol Denise McNair, who was 11. More than a dozen other people were injured, by some counts as many as 22.
Two months later, on 18 November, John Coltrane took his quartet into Rudy Van Gelder’s studio in Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey, and recorded a slow, grieving piece. McCoy Tyner was on piano, Jimmy Garrison on bass and Elvin Jones on drums.
Years later, Tyner and Jones told the critic Francis Davis that Coltrane handed out the music without saying a word about the killings. As far as they remembered, the piece didn’t even have a name yet. It came out as “Alabama”.
Years afterwards, Tyner gave the writer Ashley Kahn the missing piece. Coltrane, he said, had built the rhythms of the melody from a speech by Martin Luther King that he had read in a newspaper.
And three weeks after the session, the quartet played “Alabama” on television in San Francisco. That story is near the end.
The words King spoke at the funeral
The four girls were buried in two services. Carole Robertson’s family held their own funeral. On Wednesday 18 September, the other three girls were mourned together at Sixth Avenue Baptist Church, and Martin Luther King gave the eulogy.
He called the children “the martyred heroines of a holy crusade for freedom and human dignity”. He told the mourners that “unmerited suffering is redemptive”, and he said of the girls, “they did not die in vain.”
The jazz historian and Coltrane biographer Lewis Porter hears Coltrane’s opening phrase on tenor as a setting of exactly those words: “They did not die in vain.”
How the speech reached Coltrane
Coltrane wasn’t in Birmingham. On the day of the bombing he was in Buffalo, and over the following weeks the quartet played in Cleveland, New York, Europe and Philadelphia.
The eulogy wasn’t broadcast live either. The surviving tape was recorded locally and is missing several paragraphs. So, as Porter points out, Coltrane had no recording to work from.
What he could have seen was print. An Associated Press report by Hoyt Harwell, quoting King at length, ran in newspapers across the country on 19 September, the day after the funeral. One of them was the paper in High Point, North Carolina, where Coltrane grew up. Hundreds of papers carried the report, and Porter thinks Coltrane could easily have seen one of them, though nobody knows which.
Porter describes his matching of phrases to the eulogy as unfinished. Listen with the words in mind, though, and the opening phrase rises and falls like a preacher’s line.
Five minutes on a “live” album
“Alabama” came out in January 1964 on Live at Birdland, on the Impulse! label. Only three of its five tracks were recorded at Birdland, the New York club, on 8 October 1963. “Alabama” and “Your Lady” were the studio pieces from 18 November.
It runs a little over five minutes. Coltrane plays tenor saxophone throughout, not the soprano he used on “My Favorite Things”, and he stays mostly in the warm middle of the horn.
The opening and closing sections float free of a steady beat. Tyner holds low, rumbling chords, and Jones plays rolls and swells on the cymbals instead of keeping time. In the middle, Garrison and Jones briefly lock into a pulse and the music lifts, before Coltrane brings it back down to the lament he started with.
Listen to it on Live at Birdland. It sits beside a long, joyful “Afro Blue” from the club, and the contrast makes “Alabama” land harder.
Nina Simone wrote her answer in under an hour
Nina Simone answered the same events with words.
After the murder of Medgar Evers in Mississippi that June and the Birmingham bombing in September, she sat down and wrote “Mississippi Goddam” in less than an hour. She later called it her first civil rights song.
She recorded it live at Carnegie Hall in 1964, introducing it as a show tune for a show that hadn’t been written yet. It came out that year on Nina Simone in Concert, and boxes of promotional singles came back from radio stations with each record snapped in half.
Put the two records side by side and you hear two answers to the same week: Simone’s bright, furious tempo and named targets, and Coltrane’s slow, wordless prayer with a title as its only explanation. We tell more of her story in our guide to Nina Simone songs.
On television, three weeks later
From 26 November the quartet had a twelve-day run at the Jazz Workshop in San Francisco. On 7 December they went to the KQED studios to film an episode of Jazz Casual, the public television show hosted by the critic Ralph J. Gleason.
Alongside “Afro Blue” and “Impressions”, they played “Alabama”. Gleason introduced it by name, so the title was public by then, even if Coltrane had kept it to himself at Van Gelder’s.
The episode aired in February 1964. Watching the quartet play it in a television studio, weeks after the session, is a good way to hear “Alabama” for the first time.
The sons of Coltrane and Garrison recorded it in 2015
“Alabama” stayed in the music. In October 2015 the drummer Jack DeJohnette recorded it with Ravi Coltrane, John’s son, on saxophone and Matthew Garrison, Jimmy’s son, on bass.
It’s on DeJohnette’s ECM album In Movement (2016). Listen for how closely Ravi keeps to his father’s chant-like line while the trio gives it more space and air.
From Birmingham to Van Gelder’s studio
The bombing of the 16th Street Baptist Church on 15 September 1963 killed four girls. Three days later Martin Luther King spoke at the funeral of three of them, and his words reached newspapers across the country the next morning.
On 18 November John Coltrane recorded “Alabama” in New Jersey without telling his band its title or subject. McCoy Tyner later said its melody followed the rhythm of King’s speech. The track came out in January 1964 on Live at Birdland, and the quartet’s December 1963 television performance is still there to watch.
For more on Coltrane, start with our John Coltrane guide, our pick of John Coltrane songs and the best John Coltrane albums. There’s more on the engineer behind the session in our story of Rudy Van Gelder, and on what came next in A Love Supreme: Live in Seattle.
Note: As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
When you listen to the opening of “Alabama”, can you hear the words “they did not die in vain” in Coltrane’s line?