A Charlie Brown Christmas: The Jazz Soundtrack CBS Didn’t Want

A few days before A Charlie Brown Christmas was due to air in December 1965, its producer Lee Mendelson and animator Bill Melendez screened the finished film for CBS in New York. The executives didn’t think much of it.

They found it slow. The voices belonged to real children, not trained actors. One of the characters read from the Bible. And the music was a jazz piano trio. “The general reaction was one of some disappointment,” Fred Silverman, then a young CBS programming executive, later recalled.

It went out anyway, because CBS had already listed it in the schedule. Nearly half of America’s television audience watched it, and the soundtrack Vince Guaraldi recorded for it is now one of the best-selling jazz albums ever made.

A song on the car radio

The story starts two years earlier, with a different Peanuts film. In 1963 Mendelson was making a documentary about Charles Schulz, to be called A Boy Named Charlie Brown, and he wanted music for it. Driving across the Golden Gate Bridge, he heard Guaraldi’s “Cast Your Fate to the Wind” on the radio.

The tune had just won the Grammy for Best Original Jazz Composition. According to Guaraldi biographer Derrick Bang, Mendelson had already approached Cal Tjader and Dave Brubeck, and both had turned the job down. The critic Ralph J. Gleason put him in touch with Guaraldi, a San Francisco pianist then in his mid-thirties.

Within a couple of weeks, Guaraldi phoned Mendelson to play him a new piece down the line so he wouldn’t forget it. That was “Linus and Lucy”. No network bought the documentary, but Fantasy Records released the music in December 1964 as Jazz Impressions of A Boy Named Charlie Brown.

Six months and a Coca-Cola budget

In April 1965, soon after Peanuts made the cover of TIME, Coca-Cola’s advertising agency McCann-Erickson called Mendelson. Did he and Schulz have a Christmas special? Mendelson said yes. They didn’t, and the agency wanted an outline by the Monday.

Schulz wrote it, Coca-Cola agreed to sponsor it, and CBS took it. The team had about six months and a budget of $76,000, which by the end had crept up to roughly $96,000.

Schulz made two decisions early on. The characters would be voiced by children, some of them too young to read their own lines. And there would be no laugh track. Mendelson suggested one, and Schulz refused.

The third decision caused the most worry inside the team. Schulz, who taught Sunday school, wanted Linus to recite the nativity story from Luke’s gospel. Melendez argued that cartoons didn’t do that kind of thing. As the Charles M. Schulz Museum tells it, Schulz answered: “If we don’t, who will.”

Two trios and a church choir

Guaraldi recorded the score across several sessions between 17 September and 28 October 1965, at Whitney Studio in Glendale and at Fantasy’s studios in San Francisco. He used two rhythm sections. Monty Budwig on bass and Colin Bailey on drums played on some sessions, and the album version of “Linus and Lucy” is their 1964 recording. Fred Marshall and Jerry Granelli played on most of the rest.

The paperwork was never complete, and who played what has been argued over since a 1988 CD credited Budwig and Bailey alone. Granelli, who died in 2021, said the trio was paid a flat session fee and no royalties. He remembered it as about $120, though the figure changed between interviews.

For “Christmas Time Is Here”, Guaraldi brought in the children’s choir of St Paul’s Episcopal Church in San Rafael, which had sung with him at Grace Cathedral earlier that year. The melody began as a slow jazz waltz for the skating scene. When no lyricist was free, Mendelson wrote the words himself, in about ten minutes by his own account.

The children recorded over several evening sessions in San Francisco. Their director, Barry Mineah, wanted a polished performance; Mendelson and Guaraldi preferred the looser takes, slightly off pitch, and those are the ones you hear. The children were paid $5 (one singer remembers it as $5 a session), and she also recalls the producer handing Mineah $20 to take them all for ice cream afterwards.

What CBS saw

By the time the film was finished, only days were left before the broadcast. Melendez later recalled his own verdict on seeing it complete: “My golly, we’ve killed it.”

The network’s complaints matched his fears: the slow pace, the amateur voices, the simple animation and the music, which didn’t sound like anything else on children’s television. But there was no time to change it.

Silverman later admitted his own misjudgement: “What did I know compared to Charles Schulz?”

15 million homes

A Charlie Brown Christmas aired at 7.30pm on Thursday 9 December 1965, in place of The Munsters. Around 15.5 million homes tuned in, a 45 per cent share of the audience, and it finished second in the week’s ratings behind Bonanza.

It won the Emmy for Outstanding Children’s Program in 1966, along with a Peabody Award. CBS repeated it every year until 2000, ABC took it over from 2001, and since 2020 it has lived on Apple TV+.

The soundtrack, released by Fantasy in December 1965, kept selling for decades after the show became a fixture. In August 2026 it was certified six times platinum in the US, which its label, Craft Recordings, says makes it the best-selling jazz album ever.

Vince Guaraldi, composer of the A Charlie Brown Christmas soundtrack, at the piano in 1967
Vince Guaraldi – University of Santa Clara, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Why it sounds like jazz

Guaraldi didn’t simplify anything for children. “Linus and Lucy” rides on a rolling left-hand figure that repeats under the melody, and the trio swings it hard. “Christmas Time Is Here” is the opposite: slow, with soft, unusual chords that give it a wistful feel rarely found in Christmas songs. The instrumental version stretches past six minutes.

After Peanuts

Guaraldi went on to score 15 Peanuts television specials and the 1969 feature film A Boy Named Charlie Brown, and the work became the steadiest part of his career. On 6 February 1976 he finished a recording session for It’s Arbor Day, Charlie Brown in the afternoon, then went to play a gig at Butterfield’s, a club in Menlo Park, near San Francisco.

He collapsed between sets and died that night, aged 47. It was reported at the time as a heart attack. Derrick Bang’s research has since pointed to a ruptured aortic aneurysm.

For more festive listening, here’s our pick of the best Christmas jazz songs.

Featured image: Vince Guaraldi – University of Santa Clara, Public domain, adapted, via Wikimedia Commons

Meet Your Guide

Matt Fripp (about)

Matt Fripp

Founder & host of Jazzfuel

Matt Fripp studied jazz saxophone at London's Guildhall School of Music, then spent a decade behind the scenes as a booking agent and manager for a roster of international jazz artists worldwide. Since 2016 he's run Jazzfuel, helping close to a million readers a year dig deeper into the albums, musicians and stories that shaped jazz.
More about Jazzfuel →

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.