George Cole tells the story of a song that brought together a giant of jazz with a musical superstar.
The history of music is full of “what ifs”, and one of the biggest is the question: what if Prince and Miles Davis had recorded together in the same studio? How would they have worked together in the same room, and what type of music would they have created?
Sadly, we’ll never know, because although both men played together on stage, and even appear on two studio recordings, they never physically recorded together.
Miles and Prince play on Chaka Khan’s “Sticky Wicked”, from her 1988 album CK. The song was written by Prince for Chaka, and when Prince composed it, Miles wasn’t in consideration. Miles and Chaka were friends, and when she played him “Sticky Wicked” in the studio, he asked if he could add some trumpet to the music.
How could Chaka refuse? But Prince was not present when Miles overdubbed his trumpet in the studio, and was (presumably, pleasantly) surprised to hear Miles on the finished track.
The second recording is “Can I Play With U?”, a tune Prince composed for Miles to use on his first album for Warner Bros. For many years, “Can I Play With U?” was Miles’s equivalent of The Beatles’ song “Carnival of Light”, an unreleased track that has gained almost mythical status amongst the band’s followers.
When news broke in the mid-1980s that Miles and Prince had recorded together, there was much anticipation from fans and critics, but then great disappointment when it was revealed that the music would remain unreleased. “Can I Play With U?” wasn’t officially released until 2020, thirty-five years after it was first recorded. Why was there such a long delay, and how did Miles and Prince come to work together in the first place?
A chance meeting at LA airport
The story starts in the summer of 1985, when Miles moved from Columbia Records to Warner Bros. Prince was also on the same record label, but whether this had any influence on Miles’s decision to move to Warner Bros. is unclear. What is clear is that both men certainly knew about each other.
Prince’s father had been a jazz pianist and several of his band members, including his saxophonist Eric Leeds, had been introducing Prince to various jazz recordings, some of them from Miles.
In 1985, Prince was a megastar, riding high on the international success of his film Purple Rain, and its soundtrack album, released a year earlier. Miles, who always had an ear to what was happening on the contemporary music scene, would have been well aware of the rise of Prince and the waves he was making.
Alan Leeds (brother of Eric) was Prince’s tour manager, and recalls the first time the two men met: “To my knowledge, it was at Los Angeles airport [on] December 7 1985. I was with Prince, and we were flying back to LA. We got off the plane and were walking to baggage airside and towards where Prince’s driver was waiting.
And as we were walking through baggage claim, I spotted Miles Davis and I poked Prince in the ribs and pointed. I introduced myself and it ended up with Prince getting into Miles’s car, which was parked a little in front of his.”
Leeds remained by Prince’s vehicle: “I didn’t get in with him and they sat and chatted for twenty minutes or so and swapped phone numbers. Prior to this, Miles had signed with Warner Bros. and I’m sure there had been some conversation with Warner executives about the possibility of him doing something with Miles.
We knew Miles had aspirations beyond the jazz category, and so it was a no-brainer to think ‘We’ve got Miles and Prince under one roof, let’s get them together.’ It just made perfect sense.”
Prince writes a song for Miles in a single session
Whether Miles or Warner Bros. or both motivated Prince to submit material to the trumpeter is unclear, but Prince set out to compose a new song for Miles. Prince booked a recording session at Sunset Sound Studio 3 in Los Angeles on 26 December 1985 (by coincidence, Miles was recording at Ameraycan Studios in Los Angeles on the same day).
Prince worked quickly and intensely in the studio, as witnessed by engineer Peter Doell: “The guy was so incredibly creative. I remember days when Prince would come into the studio at like 9am, kick you out of the room for about twenty minutes, then he’d write a song – ‘1999’ was a day like that.
Then he’d come back into the [recording] room and you’d better have the drums tuned up and ready because he’s going to play the daylights out of the drums – he was an incredible drummer.
Then he’d go on and do the bass, keyboards and by one o’clock you’re mixing it and by four o’clock you run off and have it mastered. So from nine-to-five, you went from not having even written the song to having it mastered. He was an unbelievable cottage industry.”
Alan Leeds says, “The description is absolutely right – it was a phenomenal experience watching him do that. He has a very anal kind of compulsion to finish things. I suppose you could look at some of his records and say they could have benefited from a little more time, sonically as well as creatively, in some cases. But his genius was in that he would get an idea and just couldn’t rest to the degree of burning out engineers.
He was an engineer’s nightmare because he had no patience with the technology – just waiting for them to rewind tape was tedious for him, even to the point where he would yell at them and say ‘can’t you make that move a little faster?’”
Leeds adds, “He was incredibly prolific and compulsive about finishing things. It wasn’t unusual for him to get an idea for a song and go downstairs at mid-day and start, and by nine or ten at night, come up with a rough mix of a finished song.
And when you consider that he does it all himself and that a finished song represents countless overdubs of various instruments, not to mention the adjustment because the composing is part of the process. Half the time he’d have the lyric and the song would just evolve as he was working – it was pretty amazing.
But he couldn’t rest. He’s not the kind of guy who’d say ‘okay I’m going to lay down a drum track and bass track and go live with it for two days’ – the ‘live with it’ part just wasn’t in his vocabulary.”
This is exactly how “Can I Play With U?” was conceived and recorded. The best description of how Prince created the song can be found in Duane Tudahl’s superb book, Prince and the Parade & Sign O’ The Times Era Studio Sessions: 1985 and 1986.
Prince booked the studio for all day and started work at 2pm. The only people present in the studio during this session were Prince and his two engineers, Susan Rogers and Coke Johnson.
Prince started working on another song first, “A Couple of Miles”, a tribute to Miles, which remains unreleased (Prince later recorded a second tribute song, “Letter 4 Miles”, a version of which was released in 2023 – neither tune includes Miles’s playing).
That session lasted for six hours and then Prince began work on “Can I Play With U?” Using a combination of live drums and electronic drums (Simmons SDS-V), piano, guitar and Oberheim OB-X synthesisers, Prince built up the backing track, layer by layer, a process that took more than five hours.
He then spent the next two and a half hours writing lyrics and recording vocals. By the end of the session (which finished around 2.30am) a rough mix of the song had been produced.
Eric Leeds is called back from his Christmas holiday
The session continued the next day in the same studio, with Eric Leeds brought in to add horn parts to the track. He recalls how he got the call: “I was on holiday at my parents in Florida and Alan called and said that Prince wanted me to do some recording the day after Christmas.
I was a little pissed because I wanted to spend the whole of the holiday with my parents and Alan said ‘He’s only going to need you for like a couple of days and then you can fly back to Florida’ – I ended up being there for about three weeks! We were in the studio almost every day.”
Leeds took a circuitous journey from Florida to LA: “I had to fly home from Miami to Atlanta to get my horn and then go back to the airport and jump on a plane to LA. By the time I got to LA, I was fried and I knew I was probably going to be in the studio all night. I had a quick nap and then went to the studio – we used to work at Sunset Sound before Paisley Park [studios] was built.”
Leeds arrived at the studio to find Prince working on a track: “So the first thing that happens when I get there is that he has this track up and he said: ‘I’ve been talking to Miles.’ I said: ‘Really?!’ and he said ‘Yeah and I’ve got a track here that I want to send to him. Here it is, I’m going out to have dinner – do whatever you want with it.’ I said: ‘Okay.’ So I did what I did.”
Leeds overdubbed a mix of tenor sax and baritone sax parts. “Three, four hours later, Prince came back and listened to it and said ‘Yeah, that’s cool, I like it.’ So I asked him ‘How are you going to get it to Miles?’ and he said ‘Well, he’s in town, he’s in Malibu, why don’t we go to his house and give it to him?’ and I said: ‘It sounds good to me!’ So, he was on the phone to Miles the next day and then he said: ‘You know, I think we’ll just send it to him.’”
Marcus Miller writes a bridge into the Prince track
Miles received a cassette recording of “Can I Play With U?” along with a note from Prince via a messenger. In early January 1986, the multi-track tapes from the Sunset Sound sessions were sent to Miles for overdubbing his trumpet parts. By the time Miles began working on the Prince track in early spring he was recording new songs for his forthcoming new album (Tutu), with his ex-bassist Marcus Miller.
Miller heard the Prince track and realised that it sounded different from the music he was making with Miles. As a result, Miller composed a new tune, “Full Nelson”, which was meant to act as a bridge or a transition to the Prince song. Miller was also involved in an overdubbing session for “Can I Play With U?” which took place on 1 March 1986 at Capitol Records Studios, Studio B, in Los Angeles, California.
The session also involved keyboardist Adam Holzman, who had been working with Miles since October 1985. Percussionist Steve Reid also claims to have been present, but he is not listed in the official song credits, and nor is it possible to discern any percussion instruments on the track.
It could be that his contribution was left off the final mix. Miles overdubbed his trumpet (playing both muted and open horn) and most mixes of “Can I Play With U?” also include snatches of his vocals. Holzman added some synth parts, and Miller overdubbed bass, including a short slap bass section.
The multi-track tapes were sent back to Prince, who did more work on them (some of his vocal sections are double-tracked, and there are also multiple guitar parts) before the final mix was produced. The song, a midtempo funk groove, with a stop/start chorus, and dominated by guitar and horns, clocked in at around six and a half minutes.
Six mixes of “Can I Play With U?”, and only one is official
At least half a dozen mixes of “Can I Play With U?” are in circulation, most of them unofficial releases on bootlegs or posted online:
Mix 1 (2:40). This first appeared on a bootleg, Crucial, around 1990, where it was incorrectly titled “Little Red Riding Hood”. This is a very short and rough version of the song, which also runs at the wrong speed (it’s too fast) and so is at the wrong pitch. It starts with some wild, rock guitar, followed by a short atmospheric section featuring Miles’s muted trumpet bathed in reverb, and Miles muttering, “Prince, Prince, Prince.”
The song then explodes into life with Prince yelling and screaming, before it breaks out into a funky James Brown-type groove with guitar, sax and drums. Prince’s vocals are minimal on this version, as all the song’s verses have been excised – the song hasn’t been so much edited, as filleted. The song ends in a similar way to how it started.
Mix 2 (3:47). This mix has a similar introduction to Mix 1, but with Miles’s voice further down in the mix. It also runs at a speeded-up tempo, and there are more of Prince’s vocals – he sings one verse and one chorus.
Mix 3 (4:09). Another mix with the same introduction as the first two. It has more verses, a slower tempo, a longer bridge section, and Eric Leeds’ baritone sax is higher in the mix.
Mix 4 (6:25). It starts with a short reverberating electronic pinging sound before going straight into the high energy intro. Prince sings more choruses and verses, and Marcus Miller’s bass overdubs are more pronounced, especially a short slap bass section.
The track ends with a wild scream from Prince and Miles playing a short flurry of notes. This version was leaked online in 2016, giving both Miles and Prince fans an opportunity to hear the full version for the first time. Opinion about the track’s merits was divided.
Mix 5 (6:37). A similar mix to Mix 4, except there is no electronic ping at the start. The kick drum and slap bass parts are also higher in the mix. Adam Holzman’s synth overdubs are used to double up on some of the horn riffs and can be heard at the coda adding horn-like stabs to Prince’s wild vocals.
Mix 6 (6:39). This mix is the only officially released version and is on the 2020 Sign O’ The Times Super Deluxe Edition. More on this mix below.
Why the song was pulled from Tutu
Prince’s final mix was sent to Miles and the album’s executive producer, Tommy LiPuma. At this point, the track was all set to be included on the Tutu album. But after some listening, both Miles and Prince had second thoughts about the song.
To be blunt, “Can I Play With U?” is not one of Prince’s best compositions and the music leaves little space for Miles to play with. Apart from one short open horn solo section, Miles’s contribution is mainly adding a little colour here and there, playing brief runs, riffs or flurries on muted trumpet.
Talking about the track, Marcus Miller says, “The only problem with it was it didn’t seem like Miles had a lot to do on it. It sounded like he was rising over it as opposed to being in it. I think if he and Prince had spent more time together that would have been different.”
Eric Leeds says, “I don’t really know what Prince’s views were, other than he was excited about sending it to Miles. It was two or three months later that Miles had put his trumpet on it and he got it back. Prince gave me a cassette of it, but I don’t remember Prince and me sitting and listening to it together.
I played it a couple of times and other than the fact that ‘Oh my God. I’m hearing my saxophone and Miles’s trumpet on the same song.’ The music really didn’t do that much for me… it was not a particularly good Prince track.”
The only report of Prince’s reaction to the song is in Miles’s autobiography, where he noted that, “Prince wanted to put a song on Tutu, even wrote a song for it. But when we sent him the tape [of the album] and he heard what was on there, he didn’t think his tune fit. Prince has high musical standards like me. So he just pulled his song.”
As a result, “Can I Play With U?” was removed from Tutu shortly before the album went for mastering.
What the Tutu master tapes revealed in 2024
With Marcus Miller writing “Full Nelson” as a transition to Prince’s song, it was a long-held belief that “Can I Play With U?” would have been the fifth and final track on Side Two of the LP release of Tutu. But in 2024, Warner Bros. subsidiary Rhino Records released a High Fidelity LP version of Tutu that told a different story.
The album packaging included photographs of the original Tutu master tapes, along with studio documentation written by Eddie Garcia, who was the assistant engineer at Tutu’s New York sessions.
His notes show that Side Two of Tutu was originally going to include five tracks rather than the four on the eventual release. The original track running order was: “Backyard Ritual” / “Perfect Way” / “Don’t Lose Your Mind” / “Can I Play With U?” [written as “Can I Play With You”] / “Full Nelson”.
It also revealed that if “Can I Play With U?” had appeared on Tutu, it would have been an edited version with a running time of 4:10, or roughly two and a half minutes shorter than the original version. It’s also unclear whether Prince or someone else edited the track. Eric Calvi, the main engineer on Tutu’s New York sessions, who mixed five of the eight album tracks, is not sure who did the editing or when it was done: “It could have been anybody.
They’re easy edits, so it could have been Eddie with Tommy or Eddie with Marcus. I don’t remember if I did it on the spot. You may have a song that is a certain length and then you bring the fader in a bit earlier to make the whole thing a little shorter.”
The last point seems the most likely reason for editing “Can I Play With U?”, as without the track, the album’s eight songs have a total running time of 42 minutes. The addition of the edited version of “Can I Play With U?” would have increased this to 46 minutes, which is pushing at the limits of the optimal playing time for a vinyl LP (it would be another year or so before CD sales overtook vinyl).
Thirty-five years to an official release
In 2001, Warner Bros. put together a 6-CD boxed set, The Last Word, due to be released in the autumn, ten years after Miles’s death. The plan was to include several of Prince’s songs, including the full version of “Can I Play With U?”, but Prince refused permission, and the project was scrapped.
For many years, the only official release of “Can I Play With U?” was on the Canadian broadcaster CBC’s radio series on Miles, The Man With The Horn, broadcast on 30 April 1995. Episode 5 included a 45-second excerpt. The series was later released as a 5-CD boxed set.
Prince died in 2016, and since then, his Estate has released a number of albums and boxed sets from material held in Prince’s vast audio and video archive, known as The Vault. In 2020, it released Sign O’ The Times (Super Deluxe Edition), an 8-CD (plus 1 DVD) boxed set which included the first official release of the full-length version (6:39) of “Can I Play With U?”
The track has been remastered and features yet another mix. It’s busier than previous ones, featuring more trumpet and sax overdubs, and additional effects such as echo and reverb. The song’s bass elements – baritone sax, bass guitar and bass drum – have all been boosted in the mix. The coda features an extended flurry of notes from Miles at the fade-out, and at the very end, he briefly vocalises his horn riff.
The Prince and Miles Davis studio session that never happened
Miles always hoped that he and Prince would collaborate again, ideally with both men together in the studio. But although there were times when it looked like this might happen (on at least one occasion, studio time was booked for them to work together) it never materialised.
Prince was never keen on working with another artist in the studio, often preferring to create the backing track, have the artist independently add their part, and then do some additional work on the overdubbed track. (He worked the same way for two decades with the jazz arranger Clare Fischer, a collaborator he never once met.) It may also be that Prince had moved on from the idea of working with Miles, although he would continue sending him songs for consideration.
In early 1991, Miles began performing several of Prince’s songs in concert, and in March of that year, he went into a studio in Germany with his touring band to record three of them: “Jailbait”, “Penetration” and “A Girl And Her Puppy”. The plan was to include them on his forthcoming album, but Miles died six months later, before the album – and the Prince tracks – was fully finished.
It means that “Can I Play With U?” is the only studio recording on which Miles and Prince ever worked together, albeit at arm’s length. What these two musical titans might have created, had they had a much closer working relationship, will remain one of the great musical unknowns.
For more on Miles in the 1980s, read how he ended up playing a pimp on Miami Vice the same year he signed to Warner Bros., the moment he met a 13-year-old trumpeter while promoting Tutu on American TV, and our guide to Amandla, his last studio album with Marcus Miller.
Note: As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Have you heard “Can I Play With U?”, and do you think it would have fitted on Tutu?
George Cole explores the musical association between Miles and Prince in his book The Last Miles: The Music of Miles Davis 1980–1991 (published by Equinox). Interviews with Alan Leeds and Eric Leeds talking about “Can I Play With U?” and the relationship between Prince and Miles can be found on the book’s companion website, www.thelastmiles.com.