These are 10 Erroll Garner songs, from “That’s My Kick” to “Misty”, with the story behind each one and a recording to start with. Eight are his own tunes and two are standards he made his own.
Garner never learned to read music, and the Pittsburgh musicians’ union turned him down for it before making him an honorary member in 1956. He stood about 5ft 2in, and sat on a telephone book at the piano: Doug Ramsey of Rifftides noted that “He took the Manhattan directory on the road with him.” His estate counts 196 published Garner songs that were recorded, with around 200 more unpublished originals in his archive at the University of Pittsburgh.
And at the end, the reason Garner’s manager sent back his fee for a Clint Eastwood film.
10. “That’s My Kick”
Garner’s own tune, and the title track of the album that ended a five-year gap between his studio records. He cut it at RCA’s New York studios on 13 April 1966 with Milt Hinton on bass, George Jenkins on drums, Art Ryerson on guitar and the Latin bandleader Johnny Pacheco on bongos.
The guitar and bongos push his trio towards a Latin dance band. In the original sleeve notes the writer Michael Zwerin called the album “live music in your living room—and it’s a ball.”
Start with: Erroll Garner on That’s My Kick (1967), in the 2020 Octave Remastered edition from Mack Avenue. Listen for the wild solo piano introduction, one of three on the album that Zwerin singled out, before the band comes in.
9. “Paris Mist”
In 1963 Garner wrote the themes for Paramount’s A New Kind of Love, a romantic comedy set in Paris starring Paul Newman and Joanne Woodward. Garner couldn’t write a score down, so the veteran Hollywood composer Leith Stevens worked out arrangements with him, three orchestrators filled them in, and Stevens conducted a 35-piece orchestra at United Recording in Los Angeles in the summer of 1963.
None of Garner’s piano was written out. He improvised it on every take, with Barney Kessel on guitar in the band. In the album’s notes Stevens wrote: “Early in our meetings, I learned that Erroll thinks musically in terms of character, color, texture, line and mood.”
Start with: Erroll Garner on A New Kind of Love (1963). “Paris Mist” turns up three times: as the film theme, as a waltz that breaks into swing, and with just the trio.
8. “Afternoon of an Elf”
On 14 March 1955, Garner sat alone at the piano in Fine Sound Studios in New York and recorded enough music for two Mercury LPs in one session. The up-tempo pieces went on Afternoon of an Elf, and its title track is his own.
The critic Mark Stryker, writing for WBGO, described it as a 32-bar tune in A flat with “an expansive introduction” and a large coda.
Start with: Erroll Garner on Afternoon of an Elf (1955). With no bass or drums, Garner’s left hand does both jobs.
7. “Paris Bounce”
On 1 December 1957, Garner set off on his first trip to Europe in almost ten years. Back in New York, he asked Columbia’s Mitch Miller for a session so he could “record my trip to Paris”, according to the album’s sleeve notes.
On 27 March 1958, with Eddie Calhoun on bass and Kelly Martin on drums, he recorded 16 sides in a day for Paris Impressions. Miller had long pushed him to try the harpsichord, and this was the record where he finally did, on four tracks.
“Paris Bounce” is one of 12 Garner originals across the two volumes, and it stays on the piano. They sit alongside Paris standards such as “La Vie en Rose” and “The Last Time I Saw Paris”.
Start with: Erroll Garner on Paris Impressions (1958). Then go to the harpsichord tracks on the same set, “Paris Blues” and “When Paris Cries”, to hear him on the other instrument.
6. “Solitaire”
The ballads from that one-day Mercury session in March 1955 went on a second LP, Solitaire, named after the Garner original on side one. It runs over six minutes, slow and solo.
Mark Stryker put “Solitaire” with “Gaslight” among Garner’s “bittersweet ballads”. He recorded it twice more for Columbia in 1957, the second time with an orchestra conducted by Mitch Miller.
Start with: Erroll Garner on Solitaire (1955). It’s a solo ballad with no bass or drums, so you hear every chord he chooses.
Then try: Erroll Garner on Other Voices (1957), recorded with Miller’s orchestra and arrangements by Nat Pierce.
5. “Dreamy”
Garner recorded “Dreamy” on 2 September 1956 at Columbia’s 30th Street Studio in New York, with Al Hall on bass, Specs Powell on drums and a full orchestra conducted by Mitch Miller. It was the same session where he remade “Misty” with strings.
With words by Sydney Shaw, “Dreamy” opened Sarah Vaughan’s first album for Roulette in 1960 and gave the album its title.
Start with: Sarah Vaughan on Dreamy (1960). Jimmy Jones conducts the orchestra, and Vaughan’s version runs just under three minutes.
Then try: Erroll Garner’s own 1956 orchestral recording, collected on Play It Again, Erroll! (1975).
4. “Laura”
David Raksin wrote “Laura” for the 1944 film of the same name, and Johnny Mercer soon added a lyric. On 25 September 1945, Garner recorded it in New York for Savoy with John Levy on bass and George De Hart on drums.
JazzStandards.com calls his reading “a landmark recording of the tune”, adding that it “still sounds impossibly lush for a piano trio performance”. He plays it as a slow ballad, with his right hand landing just behind the beat, which became a Garner trademark.
Start with: Erroll Garner on Serenade to Laura, the Savoy LP that collects the 1945 trio sides.
Then try: Erroll Garner on Nightconcert (recorded 1964, released 2018), live at the Concertgebouw in Amsterdam, nearly 20 years later.
3. “No More Shadows”
This Garner ballad first appeared as an instrumental called “Shadows” on Closeup in Swing, recorded in July 1961. His manager Martha Glaser later commissioned lyrics for it, and by 1964 he was playing it as “No More Shadows”.
In 1964 the BBC filmed Garner playing it for Jazz 625 in a London television studio. In 2021 that solo piano opened “All Night Parking (with Erroll Garner) Interlude” on Adele’s album 30, 44 years after Garner’s death. The producer Joey Pecoraro had already built a track of his own around the same sample.
Start with: Erroll Garner on Closeup in Swing (1961), the first recording, with the trio.
For the story: Adele on 30 (2021). The Garner piano comes in first, and Adele sings over it.
2. “Autumn Leaves”
On 19 September 1955, Garner’s trio played the Sunset School hall in Carmel, California, with Eddie Calhoun on bass and Denzil Best on drums. There was no plan to make a record. Will Thornbury, who worked for the Armed Forces Radio Network, taped the show for the camp radio station at nearby Fort Ord, where soldiers had been bussed in to fill seats.
Glaser heard the tape, kept it, and took it to Columbia’s George Avakian, who released it as Concert by the Sea. The piano was out of tune, and by 1958 the LP had earned more than a million dollars. It opens with “I’ll Remember April” and also includes “Teach Me Tonight” and Garner’s own “Mambo Carmel”.
“Autumn Leaves” is the longest track on the original LP at nearly six and a half minutes. Writing for NPR’s Fresh Air in 2015, Kevin Whitehead noted that Denzil Best played brushes only, with no sticks, and that Garner often moved away from a tune right at the start, leaving the bass and drums to follow him.
Start with: Erroll Garner on Concert by the Sea (recorded 1955). Listen for the long solo introduction before Calhoun and Best come in.
Then try: Cannonball Adderley on Somethin’ Else (1958), a slow, moody version with Miles Davis and, on drums, Art Blakey.
1. “Misty”
In 1954 Garner was on a flight from San Francisco to Chicago, with a stop in Denver, when he saw a rainbow through the misted-up window. He described it years later to the drummer Art Taylor: “This rainbow was fascinating because it wasn’t long but very wide and in every color you can imagine.” He hummed the tune and played it on his knees with his eyes shut, which worried the woman in the next seat. “By the time I got off the plane, I had it.”
He recorded it in Chicago on 27 July 1954 with Wyatt Ruther on bass and Fats Heard on drums. Johnny Burke added the lyric the following year, and Johnny Mathis’s 1959 recording reached No. 12 on the Billboard chart.
“Misty” is a 32-bar ballad in E flat, and its melody leaps across nearly two octaves. Mark Stryker points out that its chords largely follow Billy Eckstine’s “I Want to Talk About You”, apart from parts of the bridge.
Start with: Erroll Garner on Contrasts (recorded 1954), the original trio version. Notice his left hand keeping a steady strum under the melody, the way a rhythm guitarist would.
Then try: Erroll Garner on One World Concert (1963), recorded live at the Seattle World’s Fair in August 1962.
For something different: Johnny Mathis on Heavenly (1959), the version that turned “Misty” into a pop song.
Clint Eastwood, “Misty” and the fee that went back
In 1971 Clint Eastwood made his debut as a director with Play Misty for Me, a thriller about a Carmel radio DJ and the listener who keeps phoning in to request the song. Garner recorded a new trio version of “Misty” for the film.
Then came an early cut. As Billy D. Scott tells it in a 2018 piece for the Erroll Garner Jazz Project, the performance had been cut into short pieces and scattered through the film, and Garner had also been asked to record shorter takes. Glaser said the deal was for one full-length version.
On 6 August 1971 she wrote to the producer, Robert Daley: “At NO PRICE is he available to record on a sound track in such abortive fashion—particularly on his own best known selection.” She told him she was returning Garner’s token fee and asked for the trio recording to be removed.
About 20 years before “Misty”, a club owner in Pittsburgh gave the young Garner another pianist’s job. That pianist was Art Blakey, who told audiences for decades that the club owner had a pistol. Here’s how Blakey ended up on drums.
Those are 10 Erroll Garner songs, from “That’s My Kick” to “Misty”, eight of his own tunes and two standards. For the records behind them, see our guide to Erroll Garner albums. There’s more on Garner and others who played by ear in jazz musicians who never learned to read music, and more great players at the keyboard in our list of the best jazz pianists.
Note: As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Which Erroll Garner performance would you play to someone who has only ever heard “Misty”?